This doesn’t really have any spoilers, but if you haven’t seen the movie yet, you may not want to read. For those who don’t care one way or the other, I will continue. I have been a Star Wars fan for about 13 years, since I was 12. I read alot the expanded universe stuff and used to be hardcore into Star Wars. While I have dulled down my Star Wars fixation in recent years, I was still excited to see the new movie. I read the book beforehand, as I did with Attack Of The Clones. I rather enjoyed knowing what was going on before watching it. Upon seeing Episode 3: The Revenge Of The Sith, I can say I couldn’t have disliked the movie more. George Lucas is a fucking hack. He had a perfectly good storyline structure and movie that could have been made from the material, but instead he opted to cram way too much into this movie, while leaving integral plots from the book on the cutting room floor. The acting was marginally better then in the previous episodes, but it didn’t matter. There was hardly any dialogue or anything memorable or quotable to be found. Everything seemed compressed so the characters could spit out what they had to say so they could get on to the next plot point. The movie was all cuts and fades all over the place. I can hardly recall a scene in the movie that actually flowed from one shot to the next aside from the starting sequence. Everything was jumping from one plot and conflict to the next. The movie had a rediculous amount of action, which is what the fans want. But when you have a lightsaber battle/duel every 5 minutes it loses it’s dramatic effect. There are, by my count, 5 different major lightsaber vs. lightsaber conflicts. Now the original trilogy had 3 lightsaber battles total. The first 2 movies each had one, though on a larger scale then the original trilogies. So this movie had the same amount as the rest of the
series, and that doesn’t include all the general use of lightsabers throughout the movie. With that added it comes across as too much. It really killed the impact of the final battle that everyone has waited for since seeing A New Hope, Kenobi/Skywalker I.
The visuals were alot of the time just thrown in gratuitously to satisfy fan cravings. There is a whole battle on Kashyyyk, home planet of the wookiees, that while cool, seemed to be tacked on for the sake of having a reason to have wookiees in the movie. In these scenes you see Chewbacca, and it’s rather obvious it’s him as soon as you see the scene, regardless of whether Yoda mentions him by name or not, but he gets called by name just for those 4 people in the theatre who didn’t know it was him. It’s this kind of heavy handed directing that really weighs this movie down. There is absolutely no subtlety to any of the direction. It’s all hit you over the head obvious, when there was no reason to be.
At other points things are just left up to guessing how they came about. It made me question at some points how people could watch the movie without actually having read the book. Some of the plot points made no sense, or just failed to be convincing in suspending your disbelief of the movie. How Anakin turns of the dark side is tenuous at best. This should have been the very core of the movie. Everyone knew Anakin had the dark in him, but I don’t think they did enough to hammer this point home. In the book it’s almost believable, but given the movie is full of so many fluff action sequences this got backburnered. The whole Star Wars saga is the rise, fall and redemption of Anakin Skywalker. How is it possible Lucas thought it was more important to show battles on numerous different planets, yet couldn’t find the time to convincingly tell the core story he claimed his whole saga was about. What the saga was really about was giving visual handjobs to all the fans of the films. Lucas was more focused on how to jam more visuals and holy shit moments into the movies that he lost focus of the big picture, delivering a memorable story.
As a big Star Wars fan I was willing to cut Lucas some slack upon seeing the Phantom Menace. It wasn’t the greatest movie, but it was watchable and I was willing to give him a mulligan on that one because he hadn’t actually directed a movie since A New Hope, 22 years previous. Then Attack Of The Clones came out. It was markedly better then Phantom Menace and definitely gave you the feeling that this was leading to something really good. I didn’t even have my hopes up that much about this one, so it’s even more disappointing that the movie turned out so wrong.
Recent Comments